Disclaimer: Your House Your Garden is reader-supported. If you buy something through links on our website, we may get compensated at NO extra cost to you.
- Last Updated: February 20, 2023
- 1:47 am
Best Coffee Makers| Coffee Makers Review & Buying Guide
Every morning millions of Americans start their day with a fresh and hot cup of coffee. According to the National Coffee Association, the average American coffee drinker drinks over 3 cups of the beverage per day. For many people, drinking coffee is a great way to boost their mood, energy level, or just take a much needed break from work.
Whatever your reason is for drinking coffee, a coffee maker will help you make delicious coffee quickly and with incredible consistency. We wanted to find coffee makers that were cost effective, easy to use, and offered users the flexibility of making multiple types and sizes of the drink.
Coffee makers are great for busy coffee drinkers since they allow you to make excellent coffee with only the press of a button. Furthermore, they are much more cost effective than purchasing coffee every day on your commute. According to NextAdvisor, making coffee at home could save you between $1,000 and $2,000 a year.
We researched the best coffee makers and found the Cuisinart DCC-3200P1 PerfecTemp 14-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker to be the best overall.
Let’s get started with the full review to see which coffee maker you like best!
Our top 3 coffee makers of 2022 are as follows:
- 1. BEST OVERALL - Cuisinart DCC-3200P1 PerfecTemp 14-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe, Stainless Steel
- 2. BEST VALUE - Hamilton Beach Brewstation Dispensing Coffee Maker with 12 Cup Internal Brew Pot
- 3. BEST SPECIALITY COFFEE MAKER - Technivorm Moccamaster Moccamaster 53947 KBGV 10-Cup Coffee Maker
Jump to Section
The 11 Best Coffee Makers 2022 Reviews
Whether you’re going for a traditional coffee maker that requires coffee grounds, or appreciate the convenience of k-cups, one of these coffee makers could be the exact appliance you need to make that perfect cup of joe:
1. Cuisinart DCC-3200P1 PerfecTemp 14-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker with Glass Carafe
Our top pick for the best coffee maker is the Cuisinart DCC-3200P1 PerfecTemp 14-Cup Programmable Coffeemaker.
If you appreciate high-tech kitchen appliances, then this coffee maker is the product you need.
Cuisinart designed this coffee maker with cutting edge coffee technology, so you can enjoy better and hotter coffee without sacrificing taste. Advanced heat technology allows this coffee maker to brew coffee at the ideal temperature, thus allowing the coffee to stay hot for longer than other, similar devices.
Since it can operate automatically on a 24-hour programmable cycle, you can set the exact time that you would like your device to start brewing, giving you full control of the process. Furthermore, if you want to enjoy a cup of coffee before the device finishes a brew cycle, you can use the brew pause function which pauses the cycle so you can enjoy a fresh, hot cup of coffee at any time.
Finally, the coffee maker is equipped with a sizeable 14-cup glass carafe, a charcoal water filter, and a reusable gold-tone coffee filter ensuring that your coffee is rich, plentiful, and delicious.
Pros
- Smart tech features such as automatic shut-off and brew-strength control
- Sizeable 14-cup capacity carafe
- Removes impurities with charcoal water filter and gold-tone coffee filter
- Advanced heat technology allows the coffee to stay hot for extended periods of time
Cons
- Lid does not pop on/off easily
- Spout for water is small so pouring water into device can be difficult
2. Technivorm Moccamaster Moccamaster 53947 KBGV 10-Cup Coffee Maker
There are coffee makers designed for convenience, and then there are coffee makers designed for experience. The Technivorm Moccamaster is a coffee maker made for the perfect coffee drinking experience.
If you wish to have perfectly brewed coffee with remarkable consistency, then this coffee maker is the best option available. The brew basket steeps the coffee grounds for 4-6 minutes, allowing the full flavor and aroma of the coffee to be extracted.
Furthermore, the copper boiling element heats water precisely, achieving an optimal brewing temperature of 196° – 205° F and then automatically shuts off when it senses that the reservoir is empty.
This coffee maker is designed for precision, being the only coffee brewer certified to brew both a half and full carafe. It does this at the flip of a switch, adjusting the brewing speed and heating element temperature to adjust for the brew size.
You can be assured that when you purchase this coffee maker, you are going with one of the best brands available. Moccamaster has been producing home coffee makers since 1968, and all of their coffee brewers come with a 5-year warranty.
Pros
- Precise brewing time and temperature ensures consistently delicious coffee
- Strong customer service and comes with a 5-year warranty
- Moccamaster has a very good brand reputation
- Full and half carafe options allow you to make a quantity of coffee fit for your needs
Cons
- Expensive
- Coffee maker is large and bulky
3. Hamilton Beach Brewstation Dispensing Coffee Maker with 12 Cup Internal Brew Pot
This sleek coffee maker allows you to ditch the carafe, keeping the coffee in a sturdy internal tank. Also, the no-carafe design eliminates the risk of glass breaking.
Convenient design elements make it very easy to use this coffee maker, such as a digital display that lets you know when to clean the coffee maker.
There are 4 options on the brew-strength selector, and we love that there is even a feature for iced coffee.
Other features such as automatic shutoff and a 24 hour pre-programmable cycle allows you to enjoy your coffee exactly when you want it brewed.
Weighing under 6 pounds and being offered at a low price point, this coffee maker is a great, convenient option that would be a nice addition to any kitchen countertop.
Pros
- Inexpensive
- No carafe eliminates the risk of breaking glass
- Cleaning reminders are convenient
- Automatic shut-off up to four hours increases product safety
Cons
- Brew station is awkward to fill
- Some components get too hot to touch
4. Redline MK1 Coffee Brewer
The Redline MK1 was made for coffee lovers.
Redline designed this product with a minimalist approach, opting to focus more on the flavor of the coffee and less on the bells and whistles you might find in other coffee makers.
This coffee maker has a heating element that rapidly brings water to temperatures between 195° and 205° F, the ideal range for brewing coffee.
The pre-infusion mode allows your coffee grinds to bloom, which is the quick bubbling up of carbon dioxide that occurs when fresh coffee is brewed.
This process helps you extract maximum flavor from the coffee.
Rather than a pause button, this coffee maker is equipped with a simple lever that allows you to pause or fine-tune your coffee brewing.
Pros
- Sleek, minimalist design
- Pre-infusion mode helps you extract maximum flavor
- Strong brand reputation for coffee products
Cons
- Device is quite large
- Some complain about a plastic taste
5. KRUPS Simply Brew Digital Drip Coffee Maker
If you’re looking for a coffee maker that is compact and modern, look no further than the KRUPS Simply Brew digital coffee maker.
The digital touch screen makes it incredibly easy to use this product. Furthermore, a one-touch start means that you can start brewing coffee quickly, without having to navigate a series of buttons.
Everything you need to start brewing coffee is included with this coffee maker, such as a coffee spoon that allows you to measure out coffee grounds.
We like that the carafe is dishwasher safe, so cleaning becomes easy.
The water window is also clear, allowing you to easily keep track of how much water you have put in the coffee maker.
Pros
- One touch operation and a digital touch screen
- Clear water window makes filling the coffee maker with water simple
- Coffee spoon is included
- Carafe is dishwasher safe making it easy to clean
Cons
- Takes a while to brew a single pot
- Coffee may not get very hot
6. Ninja CM401 Specialty 10-Cup Coffee Maker
This Ninja CM401 is jam-packed full of features to give you endless options when making coffee.
The versatility offered by this coffee maker applies to both size and style.
The coffee maker allows you to brew a super-rich coffee concentrate that can then be used to prepare delicious coffee drinks, like lattes, macchiatos, cappuccinos, etc. Furthermore, the six brew size options allow you to brew as little as a single cup and as much as a full carafe at one time.
This coffee maker is equipped with a fold-away frother, which is quite unique for coffee makers in this price range.
The water reservoir is also removable, making it easy to clean and transport to the sink to fill directly with tap water.
Pros
- Fold-away frother allows you to make frothed milk coffee drinks
- Six brew size options gives you flexibility over quantity
- Removable water reservoir for easy filling
- Can make many different types of coffee drinks
Cons
- Low brewing temperature
- Can only brew quantities of coffee that are preset
7. Hamilton Beach Craft Programmable Automatic Coffee Maker Brewer
The Hamilton Beach Craft Programmable Automatic Coffee Maker is one our top pick for an automatic pour over coffee maker.
Pour over coffee makers require more investment from the consumer, as the learning curve is higher than using a drip coffee maker, but the flavor of the coffee that results can make the process incredibly fulfilling.
By blooming the coffee and saturating the coffee grounds slowly and evenly, intense flavors and aromas are extracted during the pour over coffee brewing process.
This device makes the pour over process easy, allowing you to control brewing method, bloom cycle, brew temperature, and brew strength through a digital touch screen.
The touch screen display walks you through every step, indicating the correct quantities of water and coffee to add to achieve the perfect coffee/water ratio. Furthermore, an integrated scale allows you to measure out the perfect amount of beans for your size of brew, every time. Once the coffee gets made, it trickles down into the sturdy borosilicate glass carafe, which is equipped with an internal mixing tube to ensure even flavor.
A combination of smart features and durable design makes this product the right choice for any pour over coffee lover.
Pros
- Digital touch screen guides you through each step of the brewing process
- Users have total control over brew method, bloom cycle, brew temp, and brew strength
- Integrated digital scale allows for precision
- Durable carafe
Cons
- Some reviewers complain of a plastic smell when coffee is brewed
- Coffee filter is not enclosed
8. Calphalon Coffee Maker, Programmable Coffee Machine with Glass Carafe
Sometimes an 8-10 cup carafe is not large enough to fulfill all your coffee needs, and if that is the case then the Calphalon Coffee Maker, with a durable design and massive carafe capacity, is the answer.
This coffee maker has an impressive 14-cup carafe, so it’s perfect for households with more than one coffee drinker.
It is also designed for optimum flavor extraction, equipped with an enlarged shower head that uniformly saturates your coffee grounds.
Every component of this coffee maker was designed with intention, such as the warming plate that has settings for low, medium, and high heat and uses corrosion-resistant aluminum to heat the carafe.
Other features and design elements ensure include a dual-insulated heating tube that maintains the right temperature for brewing and a decalcification sensor that automatically indicates when the machine needs to be cleaned.
Pros
- Massive 14-cup carafe
- Warming plate can be controlled for low, medium, and high heat
- Dual-insulated heating tube ensures optimal temperature throughout the machine
- Enlarged shower head uniformly saturates coffee grounds
Cons
- Noisy
- Surface is not fingerprint-resistant
9. Bonavita BV1901PW Metropolitan 8 Cup Coffee Maker
The Bonavita BV1901PW Metropolitan may look like a simple device, but it is a powerhouse designed to help you make artisan coffee at home.
By automatically performing the pour over brewing method, this coffee maker gives you the taste of speciality coffee at home, and at a much more affordable price than if you made daily trips to your favorite coffee shop.
The 1500-watt heater brews coffee between 195° and 205° F, which is the professionally recommended temperature range.
The pre-infusion mode allows the freshly roasted coffee to bloom before brewing, helping to achieve the ultimate artisan coffee flavor.
Just because Bonavita employed a minimalist design with this product means that it lacks key digital features. This coffee maker has an auto-off feature and makes an audible signal at the end of brewing cycles. Furthermore, the carafe, carafe lid, filter basket, and showerhead are all dishwasher safe, making this product incredibly easy to clean.
Pros
- Easy to clean as carafe, carafe lid, filter basket, and showerhead are dishwasher safe
- Pre-infusion mode allows you to achieve nuanced coffee flavors
- Powerful 1500-watt heater
- Sleek minimalist design
Cons
- Carafe is hard to grip
- Some complain about coffee not being hot enough
10. Ninja CE251 Programmable Brewer
Ninja says this product is capable of producing two styles of coffee: classic and rich. Whether you prefer a classic brew or a rich brew, we believe the CE251 can make you happy with consistently delicious coffee.
If you wish to have your coffee ready for you each morning without hassle, then you can take advantage of the 24-hour programmable delay feature.
Furthermore, when you need to refill the water reservoir, it is detachable so it can easily be taken to your sink to be filled.
What we love about this coffee maker is the flavor straw in the carafe, which circulates coffee throughout the carafe while its brewing to keep the coffee hot and flavorful.
If you can’t wait until the end of a brewing cycle to enjoy your coffee, that’s alright, since this coffee maker has a mid-brew pause function.
Pros
- Mid-brew pause function allows you to enjoy coffee at any moment
- Flavor straw in carafe keeps coffee hot during brewing process
- Classic and rich flavors give you options for enjoying your coffee
- 24-hour delay feature allows you to "set it and forget it"
Cons
- Some reviewers complain about difficulties when trying to secure the lid into place
- Bulky design
11. Hamilton Beach 12 Cup Electric Percolator Coffee Maker
The Hamilton Beach 12-cup Electric Percolator Coffee Maker is designed with elegance in mind.
It is simple, but incredibly effective. The percolator can heat up to 12 cups of water for tea, hot chocolate, or coffee.
The design is durable, as the brew basket and stem made from stainless steel. Furthermore, all the components are dishwasher safe so it is incredibly easy to clean.
The best part about using this coffee maker is serving the coffee, as the aesthetic design and easy-pour spout makes pouring your coffee an enjoyable experience. Since the cord is portable and removable, this coffee maker can be used anywhere and stored quite easily in your kitchen.
An indicator light that signals when the coffee is ready is a nice touch that rounds out the functionality of this coffee maker.
Pros
- Elegant design and durable stainless steel housing
- Versatile as it can be used to brew coffee or heat tea, hot chocolate, and coffee
- Components are dishwasher safe so it is easy to clean
- Removable and portable cord is convenient
Cons
- Some reviewers complain product not lasting long
- Cannot see volume of coffee inside the percolator
Best types of Coffee Makers
The type of coffee maker you buy matters as the use cases vary.
Best Automatic Drip Coffee Maker
The best automatic drip coffee makers are the Cuisinart DCC-3200P1 PerfecTemp and the Technivorm Moccamaster 53947. Both coffee makers use precise brewing times and temperatures to make consistently delicious coffee.
Best French Press Coffee Maker
The best french press coffee maker is the Bodum 1928-16US4 Chambord French Press Coffee Maker. Bodum designed this product with heat-resistant borosilicate glass to ensure durability.
Best Pour-Over Coffee Maker
The best pour over coffee makers include the Bonavita BV1901PW Metropolitan and the Hamilton Beach Craft Programmable Automatic Coffee Maker. Both of these products are capable of blooming your coffee, which helps extract maximum flavor and aroma during the brewing process for a rich-tasting cup of coffee.
Best Aeropress Coffee Maker
The Aeropress Coffee and Espresso Maker is the best aeropress coffee maker. The controlled temperature, total immersion, and filtering that occurs with an aeropress makes it a great option for serious coffee enthusiasts.
Best Stovetop Coffee Maker
The best stovetop coffee maker is the Bialetti – Moka Express. This coffee maker is the original moka stovetop coffee maker that was designed in Italy in the 1930s. Its ergonomic handle and compact design makes it the coffee maker of choice for many coffee drinkers around the world.
Best Cold-brew Coffee Maker
The County Line Kitchen – Cold Brew Mason Jar iced Coffee Maker is one of the best cold-brew coffee makers available on the market. Its stainless steel filter and the durable mason jar ensure that you’re buying a product that will stand the test of time.
Best Percolator Coffee Maker
The best percolator coffee maker is the Hamilton Beach 12-cup Electric Percolator Coffee Maker. Its components are made of stainless steel, so it is very durable, and the coffee maker is versatile since it can also be used as a kettle.
Best Espresso Machine Coffee Maker
The best Breville BES870XL Barista Express Espresso Machine is one of the best espresso machine coffee makers. It is constructed with an integrated precision conical burr grinder which adds the right amount of ground coffee into the filter when brewing espresso.
Functionality of a Coffee Maker
The functionality that you should expect from a coffee maker includes strong heating power, a signal for when the coffee is done, a warmer plate that keeps the coffee warm long after brewing, and multiple brew-settings for your preferred strength and size of brew. Choosing the right brew strength on your coffee maker will increase the likelihood of a good cup of coffee. Brew size settings will allow you to customize the amount of coffee you wish to brew at one time. Some households will be better suited brewing a full carafe of coffee while individuals might only need to brew one cup or a half carafe. Coffee makers may also have a brew pause feature which allows you to enjoy a hot cup of coffee earlier on during the brewing cycle rather than only at the end.
What to Know for Buying a Coffee Maker
There are several things to consider when buying a coffee maker. The most important thing to look at when buying a coffee maker at is the coffee maker type. of coffee maker. being purchased. A drip coffee maker is better for those with multiple coffee drinkers like families or shared apartments, since they come with large carafes and make more than enough coffee for one person. French press coffee makers are smaller and inexpensive so they may be better for individuals or households with only one coffee drinker. An espresso machine coffee maker will be best for those who prefer espresso. Aeropress coffee makers and pour over coffee makers are great pieces in a coffee making toolkit, but they are often better suited for active coffee enthusiasts since they take longer than other brew methods and have a bit of a learning curve to them.
The overall price is another factor to consider. No matter the price point, finding a good balance between cost and features assures you value for money. This does not necessarily mean going for the priciest or cheapest option available.
Heating is a major factor when making coffee. It is important to consider the heat settings on your coffee maker. Professionals recommend brewing coffee at a range between 195° – 205° F, so it is advisable to look for a coffee maker that consistently brews coffee in this temperature range.
It is also important to select a coffee maker that is adequate for your use cases. Some features to be mindful of adjustable portion controls so you can make the quantity of coffee that is right for you, rather than always having to make a full pot. Do you need all of the different uses of a coffee maker?
An effective keep warm feature is essential. An automatic shut-off feature that prevents you from using too much power is also nice to have, as is a delay-start function so you can have your coffee ready for you in the mornings.
Price Ranges for the Best Coffee Makers
The best coffee makers come at a price range of $50-$200. Coffee makers with many preset brew options, large carafes, and advanced reusable filters tend to be more expensive than coffee makers with minimal features. Coffee makers with digital displays are also often more expensive than coffee makers that lack such displays. The material of the coffee maker is also factored in the price. Coffee makers with stainless steel housing are typically more expensive than those with lots of plastic parts.
Main Difference between a Coffee Maker and an Espresso Machine
The main difference between a coffee maker and an espresso machine are the construction and use cases of the two types of item. A coffee maker is an electric appliance used to brew coffee automatically. The strength of coffee brewed with a coffee maker may vary, but these machines typically only make regular coffee. An espresso machine uses high pressure to force water through coffee grounds for a very short period of time, producing a very concentrated coffee drink. Both machines make coffee drinks, but a coffee maker that is not an espresso machine will not be capable of producing espresso.
Coffee Maker Types
Here are 8 types of coffee makers:
Automatic drip coffee maker: An automatic drip coffee maker is a coffee maker that uses a filter-drip method when brewing.
French press coffee maker: A French press coffee maker is a coffee maker that uses a plunger method to steep coffee grounds in hot water.
Pour-over coffee maker: A pour-over coffee maker is a coffee maker where you pour hot water through coffee grounds with a filter.
Aeropress coffee maker: An Aeropress coffee maker is a coffee maker that brews coffee using controlled temperature, total immersion, and filtering.
Stovetop coffee maker: A stovetop coffee maker is a coffee maker that gets its heat from the burner on top of a stove.
Cold-brew coffee maker: A cold-brew coffee maker is a coffee maker that cools concentrated coffee and doesn’t use heat.
Percolator: A percolator is a coffee maker that continually cycles the heat by boiling water to make coffee.
Espresso machine: An espresso machine is a coffee maker that uses force to get more coffee out of beans.
Common Use Mistakes of a Coffee Maker
The common mistakes you can make when using a coffee maker include not periodically cleaning the coffee maker. Too little cleaning could result in clogs in the filter, which will make it difficult for the coffee maker to run properly. Cleaning the carafe is also very important so you can ensure that no old coffee oils set on the walls of the carafe, making future brews taste bitter. Another mistake is not using water that is clean. The quality of the water will ultimately determine the taste of the coffee, so using filtered water is best especially if your tap water isn’t of a high quality. Another mistake is setting the coffee maker to a brew-strength that does not match your preference. This will result in coffee that you will not enjoy, whether you brew it too strong or too weak. Finally, not adjusting the ingredients to your preferences may diminish the quality of your coffee. Even with the machine, it’s best to experiment, so always add the types of coffee and the quantity of grounds that suits you as a coffee drinker to achieve the best results. Using a coffee maker properly gets easier as you learn how to use coffee makers.
Standards to Determine the Best Coffee Maker
The criteria for the best coffee makers include the number of brew presets, ease of cleaning, and versatility. There are several things to consider when selecting the coffee maker. The most important question to answer is, “How well will this brew coffee?” This may be difficult to determine without trying the range of devices available. Functionality and reliability can be established by leaning on the experiences of other users.
You can do this by reading customer reviews. This will also help you gauge the lifespan of a coffee maker.
Common Complaints for Coffee Makers
Common complaints for coffee makers mainly revolve around the coffee not coming out as hot as desired. This can mean that the coffee maker did not brew the coffee at a high enough temperature, or the warming plate did not keep the coffee maker sufficiently warm.
Furthermore, users may complain about cheap or flimsy parts. If the handle for the carafe or the lid for the coffee maker themselves are flimsy, users may write a note about this in their product reviews.
Coffee makers are also sometimes criticized for making a lot of noise when brewing, and some users have even had the misfortune of their units making noise for hours after brewing while the coffee maker remains on to keep the coffee warm.
Best kitchen tool brands
Below are some of the best kitchen tool brands that also make coffee makers.
- Cuisinart: Cuisinart makes high quality coffee makers. Other kitchen tools that they produce include air fryers, food processors, and toasters.
- Ninja: They have a solid range of durable coffee makers. They mainly make small and medium sized kitchen appliances that include mixers and juicers.
- Hamilton Beach: They have a solid range of versatile coffee makers. They mainly make small and medium sized kitchen appliances that include kettles, mixers, toasters, and juicers.
- Breville: They are known for their high-end coffee makers, especially espresso machines. In addition to coffee makers, they also sell kitchen appliances like air fryers, food processors, coffee grinders, and mixers.
Top Coffee Maker Lifespan
The lifespan of a coffee maker will vary depending on the type of coffee maker and how it is used. A moderately used coffee maker with a sturdy design will have a lifespan of up to five years. This can be stretched to ten years or longer with some care.
Coffee makers that are heavily reliant on plastic or other less robust materials have an average lifespan of up to two or three years. They tend to suffer from general wear and tear. This period can be lengthened or significantly reduced depending on build quality, use, and maintenance.
Buy a Coffee Maker
Nowadays, coffee makers are widely available both online and in stores. These are some of the best places to buy them:
Walmart: Average Prices range between $49.72 and $155.76. Delivers in 1-3 days.
Amazon: Average Prices range between $43.99 and $339.00. Delivers in 1-2 days.
Bed Bath & Beyond: Average Price ranges around $59.99 and $229.99. Delivers in 2-5 days.
Target: Average Price ranges between $29.99 to $168.99. Delivers in 3-7 days.
Other Best Kitchen Tools besides Coffee Makers
We have covered plenty of coffee makers in this post. There are other kitchen tools that you can use together with your coffee makers. These include:
- Coffee grinders
- Electric kettles
Brands such as Cuisinart and Breville sell both coffee grinders and/or electric kettles.
Abigail Clemente
To say that Abigail is passionate about gardening and landscaping would be an understatement. Abigail came to Your House Your Garden team with an already exceptional portfolio as an experienced writer.
Abigail Clemente
To say that Abigail is passionate about gardening and landscaping would be an understatement. Abigail came to Your House Your Garden team with an already exceptional portfolio as an experienced writer.
Related Articles